ISSUES

What does Question 1 do?

Question 1 protects seven kinds of reproductive health care decisions in the Virginia Constitution: prenatal care, childbirth, postpartum care, birth control, abortion, miscarriage management, and fertility care. These pages explain what the amendment does for each, and what’s at stake if it fails.

Question 1 makes the right to abortion care part of the Virginia Constitution, so it can’t be restricted or banned by whichever politicians hold power in Richmond. It also allows the state to regulate abortion in the third trimester, except when a physician determines the patient’s life or health is at risk or the pregnancy is not viable.

What is Virginia abortion law today?

Abortion is currently legal in Virginia through the second trimester. In the third trimester, it is allowed only when physicians certify that continuing the pregnancy would likely result in the patient’s death or substantially and irremediably impair her mental or physical health (Va. Code § 18.2-74). But all of that is ordinary statute — a future General Assembly and governor could restrict or ban abortion with a simple majority vote.

 What would change if Question 1 passes?

  • The freedom to make personal decisions about abortion care becomes a fundamental right in Article I of the Virginia Constitution, effective January 1, 2027.
  • Politicians could no longer ban or restrict abortion before the third trimester by simple majority; changing the right would require another voter-approved constitutional amendment.
  • Reasonable limits remain: the amendment’s text says the state “may regulate the provision of abortion care in the third trimester,” with health and viability exceptions decided by a physician’s professional judgment — consistent with current Virginia law.

No politician is more qualified than a patient and their doctor to make personal decisions about pregnancy. Question 1 keeps politicians out of the doctor’s office.

Source: Amendment text (HJR 1) · Ballotpedia: Virginia Right to Reproductive Freedom Amendment (2026)

Question 1 protects every Virginian’s freedom to make decisions about contraception — including the birth control pill, IUDs, and emergency contraception — in the Virginia Constitution. Birth control is named directly in the amendment’s text.

Is access to birth control really at risk in Virginia?

It has been, recently. In May 2024, Governor Youngkin vetoed the Right to Contraception Act (HB 609/SB 237), a bipartisan bill that would have protected the right to use and prescribe contraception in Virginia (Virginia Mercury). He vetoed similar legislation again in 2025. Nationally, members of Congress have introduced bills that would restrict access to emergency contraception. Today, nothing in Virginia’s Constitution stops a future legislature from restricting birth control.

Additionally, in the same Supreme Court decision that overturned Roe v. Wade, a Supreme Court justice named Griswold v. Connecticut, which protects our right to contraception, as another case to be considered.

What would change if Question 1 passes?

  • The freedom to make decisions about contraception becomes a constitutional right that no governor or legislature can veto away.
  • Doctors and nurses are protected from being punished for prescribing or providing birth control.

Source: The Hill: Youngkin vetoes Virginia contraception bill · Amendment text (HJR 1)

Question 1 makes the freedom to make decisions about fertility care — including in vitro fertilization (IVF) — a constitutional right in Virginia. Fertility care is named directly in the amendment’s text.

Could IVF really be restricted?

It has happened. In February 2024, the Alabama Supreme Court ruled in LePage v. Center for Reproductive Medicine that frozen embryos are legally “children,” and major Alabama fertility clinics immediately paused IVF treatment for fear of criminal and civil liability (ruling text). Families in the middle of treatment were left in limbo overnight. Nothing in Virginia’s Constitution currently prevents a similar outcome here.

What would change if Question 1 passes?

  • Virginians’ freedom to make decisions about fertility care, including IVF, becomes a fundamental constitutional right.
  • Patients, doctors, and nurses are protected from punishment for fertility care decisions.
  • Families — not politicians or courts applying fetal-personhood theories — decide how to grow their families.

Source: LePage v. Center for Reproductive Medicine (Ala. 2024) · Amendment text (HJR 1)

Question 1 protects the full arc of pregnancy care in the Virginia Constitution: prenatal care, childbirth, postpartum care, and miscarriage management. It also bars the state from prosecuting or penalizing anyone over their own pregnancy outcome, including miscarriage or stillbirth.

Why does miscarriage care need constitutional protection?

Because in states with abortion bans, doctors have delayed or withheld standard miscarriage treatment for fear of prosecution — with fatal results. ProPublica documented the death of Porsha Ngumezi, a 35-year-old Texas mother of two who bled for hours during an 11-week miscarriage while doctors declined to perform a D&C, the standard treatment, in a state where providing a prohibited abortion carries up to 99 years in prison (ProPublica investigation). More than a dozen doctors who reviewed her case for ProPublica called her death preventable.

What would change if Question 1 passes?

  • Doctors and nurses in Virginia could never be threatened with prison for providing standard miscarriage care.
  • No Virginian could be investigated, prosecuted, or penalized over a miscarriage, stillbirth, or other pregnancy outcome.
  • Decisions about prenatal care, childbirth, and postpartum care stay between patients and their medical teams.

Source: ProPublica (Nov. 2024) · Amendment text (HJR 1)

Yes. Question 1 explicitly protects doctors, nurses, and patients from punishment for reproductive healthcare decisions.

What does the amendment actually say?

The amendment states that the Commonwealth “shall not penalize, prosecute, or otherwise take adverse action against an individual” over their own pregnancy outcomes — including miscarriage, stillbirth, or abortion — or against “any individual for aiding or assisting another individual” in exercising their reproductive freedom with their consent.

Why does this matter?

In states with bans, the threat of prosecution changes how doctors practice medicine. Texas doctors face up to 99 years in prison for providing a prohibited abortion, and ProPublica has documented preventable deaths after hospitals hesitated to treat miscarriages (ProPublica). Question 1 ensures that in Virginia, doctors, nurses, and patients never have to weigh a prison sentence against the standard of care. It’s simple: it protects our freedom to make decisions around pregnancy and ensures the people who provide that care don’t get thrown in prison for it.

Source: Amendment text (HJR 1) · ProPublica (Nov. 2024)